Review of Jaina Proudmoore: Tides of War by Christie Golden
by Anne Stickney Aug 14th 2012 at 5:00PM
Here’s a great review I found online that I wanted to share with my WOW fans.
Tides of War revolves around Jaina Proudmoore and the events at Theramore Isle, which we’ll see in game when patch 5.0.4 hits live servers. Jaina’s been noticeably absent duringCataclysm; while we see Theramore forces out and about in the world, Jaina herself remains firmly ensconced in her tower abode on Theramore Isle. But there’s a change on the winds, one that’s been hinted at ever since the novel The Shattering was released. In The Shattering, Jaina was told that eventually, some day, she was going to have to choose a side. In Tides of War, she makes that choice in a spectacularly dramatic fashion.
But there’s far more to this novel than just Jaina Proudmoore.
Christie Golden knows her Warcraft and knows it well. With a host of beloved Warcraft novels under her belt, she continues to shine with her latest foray into the world of Azeroth. Golden is also no stranger to Jaina Proudmoore; her novel Arthas: Rise of the Lich King fleshed out more of Jaina’s tumultuous past as well as the birth and death of her relationship with Arthas, even as Golden explored the details of Arthas’ fall. That said, the character of Jaina has never been written better — Golden has an amazing grasp on the woman and what exactly is going on inside her head.
For those wondering, given Golden’s previous novels The Shattering and Thrall: Twilight of the Aspects, if we’re going to see an overabundance of a certain green-skinned orc, you needn’t worry at all. While Thrall does make a couple of appearances in the novel, he is far from the main character or even what I’d call a supporting role. However, because of Jaina and Thrall’s peculiar friendship that has spanned the years since the Third War, his appearances are definitely needed and warranted for the purpose of the story being told here.
As for the rest of the world, first and foremost is the question of the Dragon Aspects. In the closing cinematic for Dragon Soul, we saw the Aspects lose their powers and give way to the Age of Mortals — but just what the heck does that mean? What is an Aspect, if they no longer have their powers? For that matter, what is the purpose of a dragonflight, when their purpose has been fulfilled?
All of these questions and more are answered over the course of the novel. And while we may not get a definitive answer as to just what powers have been lost, we do have a better idea of the eventual fate of the dragonflights by the novel’s end.
The Horde sees its own fare share of development over the course of this novel, and the picture is not a pretty one. Baine Bloodhoof, who previously appeared in The Shattering, takes a prominent role in Tides of War as well as Vol’jin. Both leaders are decidedly unhappy with the direction Garrosh has been taking as of late concerning his push against the Alliance. Over the course of the book, their wariness for Hellscream’s antics is both highlighted and illustrated as frighteningly warranted.
But the tauren and trolls are not the only Horde races unhappy with Garrosh’s reign. Shown too are appearances by the Forsaken and the blood elves. Lor’themar Theron takes only a token appearance in the novel, but his appearance is a noteworthy one that has me hoping we see more of him in the future. Sylvanas is equally absent; however, her presence is absolutely felt over the course of events.
Lest you think this is a Horde-centric novel, I should point out that it definitely is not. There is equal time spent between Alliance and Horde as both sides ramp up to the devastating climax of the book itself. And major players on both sides are highlighted throughout the course of the novel, deftly written with development in mind. I was surprised to see the direction that Varian’s character is taking post-Wolfheart, but it’s a good direction for the character to take. Anduin also makes an appearance in Tides of War, and it’s apparent that he is, above all else, not deserving of the goody two shoes label he’s been slapped with.
If it’s beginning to sound like there’s a lot to Tides of War, it’s because there absolutely is. The heat of war rises, a city falls, and in between, inexorably tied to it all is Jaina Proudmoore. She is the focus of the book for a good reason. She is the last one standing that is willing to take a stand for peace. She is a noted diplomat and prides herself on her diplomatic nature — but is that zen for diplomacy really wise in a world that seems hell-bent on war at all costs?
Jaina has to make some major decisions in Tides of War, and they don’t come cost-free. LikeThe Shattering, Tides of War features death and grief in a very stark, shocking manner. And like The Shattering, the death in Tides of War is meaningful and with purpose. There is no killing characters for the sake of killing characters; each death bears a significance that pulls the story along. With a name like Tides of War, it’s inevitable that we’ll see some death come into the picture — the names of the deceased however, were a shock.
The only faint sour note that the novel strikes is an attempt at introducing a romance, something that was hinted at by Dave Kosak on Twitter. It wasn’t that the love story wasn’t convincing — in fact, Golden did a much better job handling the tale here than with The Shattering and Aggra’s sudden appearance and relationship with Thrall. There was a gradual nature with this romance; it made sense.
Golden did a fantastic job introducing the situation and building up to the romance without overwhelming the reader. She did a wonderful job of making the relationship an ultimately believable one that worked within the context of what we knew about the characters involved. The problem lies in the fact that with so many other events going on that the romance was overshadowed. It could have been left out entirely, and the story still would have remained intact and none the worse for it. It was nice to see, but it felt unnecessary.
Romance entirely aside, Tides of War is at its core a story of transformation, of accepting that all things, be it beliefs, standards, or friendships, will inevitably be tested. Some will change for the better, some will change for the worse, and some will evaporate entirely. It’s a story of uncertainly trying to find a place in a world that seems to have no place for you, be it as a diplomat inexplicably standing for peace in a time of war or a flight of dragons with no purpose.
It’s also the story of an orc gone terribly, terribly wrong, one who has learned precisely all the wrong lessons from his father — and it’s the story of a Horde being torn apart by his decisions. It’s the story of a leader who stood at a crossroads of potential and chose to lead by threats and fear rather than understanding and compassion. It’s the story of a son who in the end, though some glimmers of hope appeared for his character, chose to ignore the light and instead embrace the dark.
And it’s a story of loss, of grief so utterly overwhelming that it threatens to devour the soul. The grief of a leader whose kingdom is wiped out in an instant, the grief of a woman who sees with stark certainty the pointlessness of the path she’s chosen, the grief of a daughter who finally understands the words of her father, entirely too late to do anything about it. It’s a tale of learning to cope with that grief and rise above it, a story of coming to terms with a chaotic world, of learning to adapt like water against the stony face of fate. It’s a beautifully written addition to Golden’s host of Warcraft novels, and I can’t recommend it enough.
Jaina Proudmoore: Tides of War is slated to release Aug. 28. You can preorder the hardcover edition on Amazon for $15.37 or the Kindle edition for $12.99. In addition, there’s anaudiobook version available for $23.95 on Simon & Schuster’s website.
Golden once again demonstrates a remarkable grasp on the characters of the Warcraftuniverse and writes a book that stands right up there with her previous works in quality. As with those works, I fully expect to see Tides on the New York Times Bestseller list as well. Pick this one up, whether you’re a Jaina fan or you’re wanting to see more of the explosive conflict leading into Mists of Pandaria.